Google favors temporary facial recognition ban as Microsoft pushes back – The Verge

635
2479
Google favors temporary facial recognition ban as Microsoft pushes back – The Verge

The regulation of facial recognition is emerging as a key disagreement among the world’s biggest tech companies, with Alphabet and Google CEO Sundar Pichai suggesting a temporary ban, as recently suggested by the EU, might be welcome, while Microsoft’s chief legal officer Brad Smith cautions against such intervention.

“I think it is important that governments and regulations tackle it sooner rather than later and give a framework for it,” Pichai said at a conference in Brussels on Monday, reports Reuters. “It can be immediate but maybe there’s a waiting period before we really think about how it’s being used … It’s up to governments to chart the course.”

But in an interview published last week, Smith, who also serves as Microsoft’s chief legal officer, was dismissive of the idea of a moratorium.

“Look, you can try to solve a problem with a meat cleaver or a scalpel,” Smith told NPR when questioned about a potential ban. “And, you know, if you can solve the problem in a way that enables good things to get done and bad things to stop happening … that does require a scalpel. This is young technology. It will get better. But the only way to make it better is actually to continue developing it. And the only way to continue developing it actually is to have more people using it.”

The two executives’ comments come as the EU considers a five-year ban on the use of facial recognition in public spaces. The EU’s proposal, which was leaked to the press last week and could change when announced officially, says a temporary ban would give governments and regulators time to assess the dangers of the technology.

Across the world, law enforcement and private enterprise are increasingly using facial recognition to identify people in public spaces. While proponents argue that the technology helps solve crimes, critics say its unchecked adoption undermines civil liberties and leads to increased discrimination due to algorithmic bias.

Facial recognition is a key technology used by the Chinese state in the repression of its Muslim Uighur minority, for example, and the country sells the same technology to other repressive regimes around the world. In the US the technology is increasingly used by the police via small contractors. A recent report from the New York Times shed light on a facial recognition system that can search 3 billion photos scraped from websites like Facebook without users’ consent, and is used by more than 600 local law enforcement agencies.

Pichai’s comments this week are particularly noteworthy as Google itself refuses to sell facial recognition to customers (citing fears of misuse and mass surveillance) but has not previously argued for a ban. Writing in an editorial for The Financial Times on Monday, Pichai advocated for greater regulation of artificial intelligence.

“[T]here is no question in my mind that artificial intelligence needs to be regulated,” he wrote. “Companies such as ours cannot just build promising new technology and let market forces decide how it will be used.”

CHINA-POLICE-TECHNOLOGY

Facial recognition has become portable, fitting into products like these sunglasses worn by Chinese police officers.
Photo credit: AFP/Getty Images

So far, the market is indeed dictating the rules, with big tech companies taking different stances on the issue. Microsoft sells facial recognition but has self-imposed limits, for example, like letting police use the technology in jails but not on the street, and not selling to immigration services. Amazon has eagerly pursued police partnerships, particularly though its video Ring doorbells, which critics say gives law enforcement access to a massive crowdsourced surveillance network.

In the US, at least, it seems unlikely that a nationwide ban could be introduced. Some cities in America like San Francisco and Berkley have independently banned the technology, but the White House has cited such measures as examples of regulatory overreach. The government has indicated that it wants to take a hands-off approach to the regulation of AI, including facial recognition, in the name of spurring innovation.

635 COMMENTS

  1. I’d like to withdraw $100, please toradol phenergan decadron A federal judge in the southern city of Curitiba ordered the arrest of André Vargas, former congressman for the ruling Workers’ Party, as well as Luiz Argolo and Pedro Corra, former lawmakers for the smaller opposition Party of Solidarity.

  2. Unless your doctor suggested this combination, you should not take Tadalafil in addition to other alpha blockers, prescription or over-the counter medicines, herbal supplements minerals or supplements. Such signs as pyrosis ( heartburn ), pain in the spine, frustration, flushing, chest discomfort, erection that lasts longer compared to 4 hrs, acid indigestion, and stale or runny nose are feasible and you will need to look for emergency situation clinical assistance if they take place. You will certainly have to tell your physician if you have low blood tension, retinitis pigmentosa, red blood cell disorder, kidney illness, recent movement or congestive heart failing, heart condition, breast discomfort, higher blood tension, hemorrhaging condition, recent cardiac arrest, belly abscess, liver illness, heart rhythm trouble or are presently making use of prescription antibiotics, barbiturates, ketoconazole, HIV or AIDS medicines, phenytoin, rifampin, heart medications, doxazosin, miconazole, carbamazepine, terazosin, antidepressants, voriconazole, prazosin, tamsulosin, rifabutin, rifapentine or itraconazole. tadalafil generic canada 20 mg is reliable just as long as you take it – meanings a new dose must be considered you to get all the advantages of your procedure. The effects of this medicine are based on Tadalafil raising the blood circulation to certain areas of the physical body.

  3. I’d like to cancel a cheque will phenergan help me fall asleep Whatever Iliad’s final bid, Deutsche Telekom has a toughdecision to make between making a quick exit from the UnitedStates to concentrate its resources on Europe and confrontingthe big investment challenges in the United States if it stays,said Hannes Wittig, an analyst at JP Morgan.

  4. I came here to study valtrex zovorax A few months ago I met Dr Saul Villeda, a biologist at the University of California, who has been doing some extraordinary research looking at what happens if you inject blood from young mice into old mice

  5. Where are you calling from? use of penegra xpress “We believe the recent sell-off provides an attractiveentry-point into the stock, even for those – like us – whoare only prepared to value the synergies and cash return,” theanalysts wrote in a note.

  6. I really like swimming atarax hydroxyzine 2hcl That is a skills education issue which the coalition government is becoming much more aware of which is a really good thing and it is great to see all these initiatives around coding and so on, but that is a decade long solution and I need developers this afternoon

  7. I’m originally from Dublin but now live in Edinburgh rebound hypertension with catapres Both Matthew McConaughey and Jared Leto delivered stirringspeeches when they won best actor and best supporting actor for”Dallas Buyers Club” at the Golden Globes last year that somehave said helped lock in their subsequent Oscar wins.

  8. Good crew it’s cool 🙂 http://xxxxxxxxx.in.net/ xxx hot video Dell also agreed on Friday to reduce from $450 million to$180 million a break-up fee it would have to pay if the dealwith Michael Dell and Silver Lake was terminated, and if withina year it enters into another transaction that does not lead toany party being a majority shareholder.

  9. Could I ask who’s calling? clotrimazole lozenges for oral thrush The artist's move, she added, represented an even greater 'awakening' than her first exposure to surrealism in London and the traditions and culture of Mexico chimed with the themes surrealists were already exploring – particularly those surrounding death and religion.

  10. I’d like to take the job http://madthumbs.fun/ mad thumbs Tynes leaves the Giants with several memories. His two biggest kicks came in separate NFL championship matchups (2007 and 2011) as Tynes converted game-winning field goals in overtime to send the Giants to the Super Bowl.

  11. Could I have an application form? purchase warfarin test strips Doctors, faced with mass casualties on an unprecedented scale, pushed the boundaries of medical science, women left the confines of the home and volunteered as nurses, and thousands of escaped slaves got their first taste of freedom

  12. Recorded Delivery http://xnxxxnxxmom.in.net/ xnxx porno “As a company with deep roots in New England and a strong presence in Boston, we believe this is the right decision out of respect for the victims of the attack and their loved ones,” they said in a statement.

  13. By age
    instagram account : account+mail : age from 5 to 9 years $1.2
    instagram account : account+mail : age from 4 to 5 years $1
    instagram account : account+mail : age from 3 to 4 years $0.90
    instagram account : account+mail : age from 2 to 3 years $0.80
    instagram account : account+mail : age from 1 to 2 years $0.70
    instagram account : account+mail : age from 12 months to 1 year $0.60

    Posts+Followers
    instagram account : age from 2 to 7 years : Publications from 20 : Followers 20-100 $1.50
    instagram account : age from 2 to 7 years : Publications from 20 : Followers 100-250 $1.60
    instagram account : age from 2 to 7 years : Publications from 20 : Followers 250-500 $1.70
    instagram account : age from 2 to 7 years : Publications from 20 : Followers 500-999 $1.80

    Where you can contact me,PM me here!
    https://sellaccs.net

    Skype & Telegram : congmmo
    ICQ : @652720497
    Email : [email protected] . com

  14. 10 AGED INSTAGRAM ACCOUNTS 2012-2017
    This are 10 basic accounts with no posts, created between 2015 and 2017.
    Contact me for more information

    Price
    $30 using playerup middleman or $25 if you buy directly from me​

    How to buy?
    To buy this account just click on “Buy now”. Playerup will keep the money and I deliver the accounts to you. I can give you a discount if you buy directly from me.

    Payment method if you buy directly from me
    Crypto, paypal, skrill, csgo skins

    Where you can contact me,PM me here!
    https://sellaccs.net

    Skype & Telegram : congmmo
    ICQ : @652720497
    Email : [email protected] . com

  15. I’m on work experience traitement parkinson sinemet In the emotional aftermath of the grand jury’s refusal to indict a police officer in the chokehold death of Eric Garner on Staten Island, New York is weathering a challenging period of turbulence under the deft command of Police Commissioner Bill Bratton.

  16. I’m on business tanaflxy.com.
    Cedar Point, which says it has been rated the best amusement park in the world for 15 years in a row, is in Sandusky, along Lake Erie between Cleveland and Toledo. It’s owned by Cedar Fair Entertainment Co.

  17. A financial advisor http://trannytube.fun/ tranny tubes — Arshi Siddiqui, who represents physicians, the movie industry, Siemens Corp., United Technologies Corp., UPS, and life insurers, met one-one-one with Obama economic adviser Jason Furman twice in April.

  18. This is your employment contract nnhentsi
    MrKelvin, who has a 36.3% stake in the brand he founded 25 years ago, said hesold some shares during the summer to increase liquidity due to demand forminstitutional investors. He said: “I am not a seller. I am not that materialistic.I am driven by how better not how much.”

  19. What’s the interest rate on this account? yukino takeuchi bonnosokubosatsu
    German executives had become frustrated with American salesmanagers, who they felt had botched the job of marketing thesmall cars built in Pennsylvania. In turn, said the former VWexecutives, who requested anonymity, the Americans blamed theGermans for failing to offer updated designs to the boxy Golf orfeatures American buyers demanded, like cupholders.

  20. [url=http://fr.musclemass.space/faire-muscle-rapidement/]http://fr.musclemass.space/faire-muscle-rapidement/[/url]

    I like reading your web site. Cheers!

  21. [url=http://it.t-booster.org/prendere-testosterone-per-palestra/]prendere testosterone per palestra[/url]

    You’ve astonishing knowlwdge on this site.

  22. I’m afraid that number’s ex-directory madam jada xfantasytv
    Until recently, he would smoke right outside his apartment door, inside a breezeway. But, the Executive Director of the Newington Housing Authority, Melinda Harvey, says a complaint for an anonymous resident and observations by NHA staff led to the eviction notice.

  23. I like watching football femalegra Meanwhile, the survey also found that when first diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, 23% were scared by the news and 22% felt regret, while over 40% of people said that the most difficult part about living with the condition was worrying about possible complications, which include heart disease, kidney damage, vision loss and foot ulcers.

  24. What do you do? planetsssssy
    Ayako Sera, market economist at Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Bankshared a similar view. “It might be counterintuitive that thedollar rose on news that a dove is likely to be the next head ofthe Fed, but the news itself removed some of the uncertainty,and therefore contributed to risk-on sentiment.”

  25. Can I take your number? norethindrone 5 mg oral tablet For almost a quarter of a century I’ve been filing stories from this city.I started doing pieces on the art sales market, moved on to the Royal Family and the arts, then by a simple twist of fate found myself doing hard news and loving the adrenaline rush of deadline.I know this Britain inside outand if I may be immodest I know it more intimately than most other American correspondents, so believe me when I tell you in this first notebook:

  26. Through friends mad thjumbs
    He was acquitted of the most serious charge, “aiding the enemy,” which would have given him a mandatory life sentence. The difference could be academic: Manning could still be given up to 90 years in prison, which, even for a 25-year-old, amounts to life behind bars.

  27. I live in London hqpprmer
    “With Alcoa kicking off the earnings season in style last night and numbers topping estimates, there appears to be a degree of confidence about the round of corporate numbers we’ll be seeing in the coming days,” said Mike McCudden, head of derivatives at Interactive Investor.

  28. I’d like to tell you about a change of address http://tubegalore.in.net/ tubegalor Stephen Brobeck, executive director of the CFA, says even if education and job type were correlated with car accidents, it does not necessarily justify the use of those factors in determining auto coverage. “Instead, they should use factors such as miles driven, the frequency and severity of accidents caused and moving violations,” he says. Last year, a CFA survey found that most people do not approve of the use of education and occupation to set car insurance rates.

  29. I’ve only just arrived erectafil 20 combitic The Senate and Assembly organization committees voted along party lines to start the session on Tuesday with a hearing on the proposed right-to-work bill in the Senate labor committee, followed by a full Senate discussion on Wednesday.

  30. I’d like to send this letter by nhentai.nnet
    Bridges are normally cheaper. But a UK-Ireland bridge would have to be long. Donghai Bridge at 20.2 miles linking Shanghai and offshore Yangshan is sometimes called the longest sea bridge. In the most realistic locations, a bridge to Northern Ireland or the Republic would be even longer.

  31. What’s the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas? +ixxxx .com
    The BOJ expects the sales tax increase to shave about 0.7 percentage point off growth. For now, it sees no need to expand its stimulus further, confident that the world’s third-largest economy can withstand the hit.

  32. Will I have to work shifts? liberal family yumstories
    Obama said the remark showed what the shutdown drama was about: “This whole thing is about one thing, the Republican obsession with the Affordable Care Act. That seems to be the only thing that unites the Republican Party right now.”

  33. I’m afraid that number’s ex-directory thisavicom
    “We have made substantial investments,” said Robison, explaining that Scottish athletes would have access to a “fantastic new velodrome and a fantastic new sports arena” in Glasgow as well as a new £25m performance centre for sport in Edinburgh.

  34. Accounts are ALL made in 2011 – 2014 ! They are HIGH Quality accounts and 100% secure (They come with OGE) – Mail Access included

    What are these used for? Growing, Claiming, Botting – These accounts are more likely to hit explore & will grow faster!

    1 Account is $4
    https://sellaccs.net

    Skype & Telegram : congmmo
    ICQ : @652720497
    Email : [email protected] . com

  35. What sort of music do you like? claritin cats Trial judge Anthony Leonard QC told them that while a jury would not ordinarily be told a defendant had already faced a trial, it was “sensible” to do so in this case as it was likely some jurors would remember the earlier hearing.

  36. I’m on business mommy got boobs xvideo2
    At present its Addis Ababa-based factories and tannery to the south of the city employ about 1,200 locals, a number expected to grow to about 5,000 within five years. A fourth factory has already been built, and is waiting to be occupied.

  37. We used to work together xxxgjrati
    Democrats have mostly walked in a straight line behind the Obama Administration, rarely showing party divisions which have plagued the GOP in recent years. But this week when it comes to student loans, the White House and Republicans are united, and it’s Senate Democrats who are divided.

  38. Thanks funny site xhumstar2
    The United States had been the largest exporter of broilerproducts to China, but the duties cut its exports by some 80percent. U.S. chicken exports to China in 2012 were 95,000tonnes valued at $113.5 million.

  39. real beauty page wifeelovers
    (Reporting by Richard Weizel, Tim Reid, Thomas Ferraro, Mark Hosenball, Caren Bohan, Alina Selyukh, Brendan O’Brien and Alex Dobuzinskis,; Writing by Susan Cornwell; Editing by Alistair Bell, Jim Loney and Peter Cooney)

  40. This site is crazy 🙂 finpecia tablets-wikipedia “I am extremely saddened to learn about the stampede at Kamtanath Pahad Temple in Madhya Pradesh, in which a number of devotees, including women, lost their lives and many others were injured,” Mukherjee said in a message.

  41. Three years hhtps://vporn.com
    Toshi Aline Ohta Seeger was born in Germany to an American mother and a Japanese father and was brought to the United States as a baby. She met her future husband as a teenager in New York City when Pete Seeger performed at a square dance and he stayed after to dance.

  42. Recorded Delivery bbypocah mega
    Both fine-particle air pollution and noise pollution may increase a person’s risk of developing cardiovascular disease, according to German researchers who have conducted a large population study, in which both factors were …

  43. Incorrect PIN xxxxvbm
    That hasn’t stopped some conspiracy theorists from ruling out explanations like devil-worshipping, however — a popular misconception for the symbol used by Mesopotamians, Greek Pythagoreans, Christians, Freemasons and Wiccans, according to historians of religion.

  44. Is this a temporary or permanent position? hqpor.comer
    Ma denies he made such an assertion siding with the government and the journalist, too, has said her report for the South China Morning Post this month was changed in editing, and she has apologized to Ma. The daily, though, is standing behind the story.

  45. very best job clilphunter.com
    The Sri Lankan case follows a major global food scare involving New Zealand’s Fonterra, the world’s biggest dairy exporter, which said on August 3 some of its products could contain a bacteria that can cause botulism.

  46. I’m sorry, she’s vqqporn
    Speaking in Melbourne Kevin Rudd, Australian Prime Minister, said: “This underlines the need for policy changes in Australia on asylum seeker’s policy which sends a very clear message to people smugglers to stop sending people by boat to Australia. We are seeing too many drownings, we are seeing too many sinkings, too many innocent people being lost at sea”

  47. Hey there! Someone in my Myspace group shared this site with us so I came to look it over. I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers! Wonderful blog and amazing design.

  48. you’re in point of fact a good webmaster. The site loading pace is amazing. It sort of feels that you’re doing any unique trick. In addition, The contents are masterwork. you’ve done a magnificent process in this subject!

  49. Hi there! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my previous room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing!

  50. Este artigo irá ensinar-lhe como construir relações com os clientes, e expandir o seu público usando estratégias como o e-mail marketing. Se você quiser começar a empregar algumas estratégias avançadas de marketing de afiliados, leia este artigo.

  51. Hey there would you mind letting me know which hosting company you’re working with? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different web browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most. Can you recommend a good hosting provider at a fair price? Thank you, I appreciate it!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here